Sunday, April 4, 2010

Common Sense Responses to Common Complaints

I very rarely write posts about educational theory, educational philosophy, or the politics of public education not because I don't have ideas, but because that's not the purpose of this blog. But, it is my blog and I do have ideas so this morning I'll venture off course just a bit. If you don't like this post, don't worry. I promise that the next 100+ posts will be focused on free resources for education.


Anyone that has spent more than a few minutes in a teachers' break room can probably tell you that the most common complaints from teachers center around disagreement with administrative decisions. Another common complaint, more common amongst younger teachers, is about low salaries. I'm as guilty as the next teacher of engaging in these complaining sessions. However, over time my response to hearing these complaints from other teachers has changed from joining into the complaining to blocking out the complaining plowing ahead to do my best for my students. (Although again I still do complain sometimes, I just try to do it less).

Yesterday, I read a post from Dr. Scott McLeod that really reflects my newer (relatively) thinking about the common complaints of teachers about the state of public education. After listing the responsibilities of school leaders McLeod writes,
"
We can point fingers. We can blame others. We can rail against the system. But we must recognize that we are in charge of the system."

He then goes on to write,
"We must point those fingers inward."

Granted, McLeod is addressing school administrators, but I believe those same ideas can be used by classroom teachers too. We can complain that we don't have the computers we know students need, or that we don't have the least restrictive Internet environments we need, but that shouldn't stop us from trying to creatively work around those problems and bringing those problems and our solutions to the attention of administrators in constructive manners.

Dr. McLeod's post reminded me of something Diana Laufenberg wrote last summer. In No One is Coming for Us! Diana addresses teachers with this,

"Many teachers are looking around wondering where the leaders are, who will ‘allow’ them to implement their big ideas for change. The thing that I have come to realize, people, is that NO ONE IS COMING FOR US."

Diana goes on to encourage teachers to stop waiting for permission to make changes in their instruction and to just start making the changes they need to make. Reading Diana's post last summer and again this morning reminded me of Seth Godin's Tribes.In Tribes Godin, like Diana, also implores leaders at all levels to stop waiting for permission to lead. Implementing change without permission can be a risk. Yet if we are to do our best for our students we owe it to them to take that risk.

On the topic of salaries, my friend and special education teacher Harold Shaw wrote a no-nonsense response to complaints about low salaries. Using simple mathematics Harold explains to teachers that we need to make apples to apples comparisons when comparing our salaries to other public sector employees. While Harold's analysis won't put more money in your pocket, it might make you feel a little better about your salary.

9 comments:

Harold Shaw Jr. said...

Rich thank you for including my Apples to Apples blog in your blog post.

The teacher's room in most schools is a place where we do hear a lot of complaining, but it is not different than break rooms at most places of work - almost everyone seems to complain about where they work, almost a universal theme.

I don't go there very often, but when I do, it is however, a great place to get ideas for my blog.

As teachers I believe that we have more control over what is going on in our classrooms and schools than we sometimes believe.

I hadn't read Diane's blog post before, but it made a lot of sense and I am glad you linked to it. More people should read it or read it again.

Scott's blog from yesterday was a powerful message to administrative types and professors, but as you said it can also apply to teachers.

Thank you for a very thought provoking blog today. Although it isn't purpose of your blog, you do have some very important views to share with other teachers.

Thanks again,

Harold

Tori Jensen said...

Thanks Richard, I am so glad you posted this or I may never have found Mr. Shaw.

Patricia said...

An administrator once said to me, " Don't tell me what you can't do, tell me what you CAN DO!" I thank her everyday for putting my teaching into perspective.
As I prepare myself to reenter the work force tomorrow morning, I want to thank you for reminding me that it is what I DO to engage and motivate students that matters most.

Tim said...

Thanks for writing this post--I've been examining the idea of how people in the tech community can leverage their...connectedness?... to bring more educators into the political processes that form the entire context of our profession. More on that later, but let me just say that here in Illinois, teacher and other public employee pensions were just seriously diminished for future employees--it's an interesting message about the value of teachers. I think we all need to write more political and policy posts, and I'm glad you did.

Rei said...

Hi Richard,

Thanks for sharing all the resources. I recently read about a newly launched website by Google Maps called Sepia Town. The "Then/Now" button on the website allows users to view a historical/vintage photograph of a given location side by side with its current appearance on Google Street View.

http://www.sepiatown.com/

Hope it will be useful for your history class. :)

Roger said...

Hi
Thanks for your post. It really does ring true. You may have seen the short video about people being stuck on the escalator, because they wait always in the hope that 'someone will come.'
In our own way, in our region here in NSW Australia, we have worked from the view that "we can't wait for the storm to blow over. We have to learn to work in the rain.' In so doing, we have provided a scaffold for teachers and others who may want to collaborate online. Our COWs - Collaborative Online Workspaces, now number around 100, and it's all about learning from and with each other, and developing new ideas and solutions. Would love you to check out what we are doing at http://hccweb2.org
I'll be showing off these spaces at a national conference in Melbourne Australia this week.

Roger said...

Hi
Thanks for your post. It really does ring true. You may have seen the short video about people being stuck on the escalator, because they wait always in the hope that 'someone will come.'
In our own way, in our region here in NSW Australia, we have worked from the view that "we can't wait for the storm to blow over. We have to learn to work in the rain.' In so doing, we have provided a scaffold for teachers and others who may want to collaborate online. Our COWs - Collaborative Online Workspaces, now number around 100, and it's all about learning from and with each other, and developing new ideas and solutions. Would love you to check out what we are doing at http://hccweb2.org
I'll be showing off these spaces at a national conference in Melbourne Australia this week.

jacquelinefg said...

I want to thank you for this. I am currently a student teacher at a middle school, and I am always hearing the teachers around me complain. They always tell me I am naive because I say that I am doing what I do for my students. Considering I am a student teacher, I have taken some risks that the teachers will not necessarily take. I see the students love the technology I have introduced, as well as bringing their outside world into the classroom. My only hope is that I will always be able to carry this with me throughout my entire career. Your blog lets me feel like there is hope.

Alie Quinn said...

Thanks for your post, Richard. Your mention of Godin's 'Tribes' was the second I had seen that day. I since have downloaded an audio version of the book and am really enjoying it.
Thanks again.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...